Get the feed in a reader!Get updates by email!Get updates by email!

ExUrbanis

Urban Leaving to Country Living

Robert Frost’s STOPPING BY WOODS ON A SNOWY EVENING illustrated by Susan Jeffers

January6

Stoppng By - Jeffers3 star ratingI love Robert Frost’s poem Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening, and even if you are in the minority that doesn’t feel the same way, you’re no doubt familiar with some of the lines.

I was very pleased to see this book on a sale table and snapped it up, looking forward to reading the poem again.
But the artist Susan Jeffers has used only the first and last stanzas of Frost’s poem, along with a couple of stray phrases from the third verse to accompany her drawings of snowy woods. To me, the original rhythm of the piece was lost and despite the art, I was disappointed.

In addition, the rotund figure with the white beard in the horse-drawn sleigh suspiciously styled after Santa’s disturbed me. I don’t believe this was ever intended to be a Christmas poem and I resent that Jeffers seems to have appropriated it for that purpose.

I might have forgiven that if the poem had been intact. The artwork deserves 3 stars.

Written by: Robert Frost 1923
Illustrated by: Susan Jeffers 1978
Published by: Dutton’s Children’s Books, NY 1978

Canadian link:
Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening


Add to Technorati Favorites

posted under Picture Books
2 Comments to

“Robert Frost’s STOPPING BY WOODS ON A SNOWY EVENING illustrated by Susan Jeffers”

  1. On January 21st, 2013 at 8:19 am J.G. Says:

    I think I agree with you! If I didn’t worship this poem, I might consider this approach a nice freshening of perspective. But really, why mess with perfection?

  2. On January 22nd, 2013 at 11:00 pm Debbie Says:

    I agree, Jane. I had very conflicted feelings rating this only a three but …

Email will not be published

Website example

Your Comment:

 
Error! Missing PayPal API credentials. Please configure the PayPal API credentials by going to the settings menu of this plugin.

RSS
Follow by Email